CIPP vs Pipe Bursting

When it comes to fixing a problematic pipe, trenchless plumbing technology offers a hassle-free solution. With this technology, you don’t have to worry about digging up large areas of your property and disturbing your landscaping, or even going under an object that you don’t want to dig up. The best part is that trenchless technology allows you to repair most common pipe issues and even replace an entire pipe without any excavation. There are two popular trenchless solutions available: pipe bursting and cured-in-place pipe (CIPP) lining. But how do you decide which one is best for your situation? Let’s explore the details of each method to help you make an informed decision.

How CIPP Lining Works
If you are experiencing issues with gaps, cracks, or other faults in your pipe, you may want to consider using CIPP lining. This method involves reinforcing your existing pipe by feeding an epoxy-coated liner into it and curing it to the walls of the pipe using an inflatable bladder. It’s essentially like having a brand-new pipe installed inside the old one.

One of the benefits of CIPP lining is that the old pipe can provide an additional layer of protection for the new lining. Additionally, for minor issues like small gaps and cracks, CIPP lining may be a more affordable and less invasive solution than pipe bursting.

However, it’s important to note that buildup in the pipe walls can further reduce the diameter of the new lining, which means that the pipe needs to be cleaned of such buildup prior to lining it.

How Pipe Bursting Works
Pipe bursting is a trenchless method of replacing old and damaged pipes. This process involves using a steel bursting head that is inserted into the pipeline at one end and a chain that is run from the head to a designated exit point. The bursting head is then used to fracture the old pipe, which is destroyed and replaced with a completely new pipe.

One of the main advantages of pipe bursting is that it allows for the replacement of the old pipe without losing the internal diameter of the pipes. This means that the new pipe being dragged into place by the bursting head will be the same size as the original pipe, resulting in less risk of restricting water flow in the pipe after the operation is finished.

Moreover, the replacement process is not affected by the condition of the old pipe, except in cases where the pipe is completely collapsed and filled in, blocking the path of the chain dragging the bursting head. In such cases, the replacement process may be a bit more challenging, but in most cases, damage to the pipe wall will not affect the replacement process.

In summary, pipe bursting is an effective and efficient method of replacing old and damaged pipes, allowing for a more complete pipe replacement.

Which is Better?
When it comes to fixing problems in your pipes, there are two main solutions: CIPP lining and pipe bursting. CIPP lining is a cost-effective method that can address simple issues by patching up any holes or quirks in the pipe. However, if you’re looking for a more comprehensive fix, pipe bursting provides an entirely new line.

Choosing the right solution can be challenging, especially if you’re not familiar with the options. That’s why it’s best to consult with experienced trenchless plumbing experts who can assess your situation and provide an estimate. The good news is that many trenchless plumbing repairs can be performed the same day, so you won’t have to wait long to get your pipes fixed.

What are the Benefits of Pipe Bursting

Did you know that there’s a way to repair pipes without digging trenches? It’s called pipe bursting and it’s a pretty neat procedure. Let me explain it to you in a bit more detail! Purposefully burst a pipe? Why in the world would you do that?
Well, for those not familiar with different plumbing procedures, it’s easy to see why you might take this view. As strange as it sounds, though, bursting pipes is actually a very effective method for repairing them.
Just as its name suggests, the repairer of the pipe intentionally breaks the existing pipe using mechanically applied force. The resulting pipe fragments are forced into the ground, and a new pipe is then pulled in to replace the original one.
As you might imagine, there are quite a few benefits to employing this particular method when repairing a pipe. Before we get into the benefits of pipe bursting in Cincinnati, we’d like to briefly go over the specifics of the procedure with you.

How Pipe Bursting Works
Pipe bursting is an innovative process used for replacing old, damaged pipes with new ones. This method involves breaking the old pipe and pulling a new one into place. The process begins by attaching the rear end of the bursting head to the new pipe and the front end to a pull rod. The new pipe and bursting head are then launched, and the pull rod is pulled from the receiving pit. The force required to break the old pipe comes from the hydraulic power or the pulling rod, depending on the system being employed. This force temporarily expands the diameter of the old pipe, and the bursting head is pulled through the debris, creating a temporary cavity and pulling behind it the new pipe from the insertion pit.
To maintain alignment and ensure uniformity during the process, the nose portion of the bursting head is usually smaller in diameter than the existing pipe, while the bottom is larger than the inside diameter of the old pipe. The bursting head bottom is also a bit larger than the outside diameter of the new pipe, which reduces the friction on the new pipe and provides space for situating the pipe.

This innovative process was first developed in the UK by D.J. Ryan & Sons in the 1970s for the replacement of small-diameter 3 and 4-inch cast iron gas mains. It was later patented in the UK in 1981 and in the US in 1986. The pipe bursting technique has seen widespread adoption in the North American gas, water, and sewer industries over the last 30 years due to the enormous benefits it offers.

Benefits Of Pipe Bursting:
Less Labor-Intensive
Pipe bursting is a trenchless method of replacing old and damaged pipelines. Unlike traditional methods that require digging and excavation, pipe bursting involves minimal digging and is less labor-intensive. With pipe bursting, large machinery is not necessary, and contractors do not have to break their backs shoveling dirt. This method is more efficient, cost-effective, and less disruptive to the surrounding environment.

The Pipe Bursting Process Causes Less Damage To The Site
When it comes to repairing sewer pipes, pipe bursting is a method that offers several advantages. First and foremost, it causes minimal damage to the surrounding area, which translates to less cleanup and repair work. In addition to being less intrusive, pipe bursting is also an eco-friendly option compared to traditional methods that involve excavation. During excavation, there is a higher likelihood of hazardous materials being handled, which can be detrimental to the environment. With pipe bursting, there is no digging involved, which eliminates the possibility of toxic substances entering the water supply or causing harm to the surrounding land.

The Pipe Bursting Process is Cost-Effective
If you’re faced with the daunting task of repairing a damaged sewer pipe, you may be wondering which method is the most cost-effective. It’s worth considering pipe bursting as an option, as it can ultimately save you a significant amount of money.

When you opt for traditional repair methods, such as excavation, you’ll need to hire multiple workers to dig a hole large enough to access the damaged pipe. Once the repair is complete, you’ll also need to pay for the site to be cleaned up, which can include hiring landscapers and purchasing new soil, grass, and plants. All of these expenses can add up quickly, leaving a significant dent in your wallet.

Alternatively, pipe bursting requires only a few workers to complete the job. This method uses a specialized machine to burst the damaged pipe and replace it with a new one, leaving the surrounding site intact. By avoiding the need for excavation and landscaping, pipe bursting can be a more cost-effective option for sewer pipe repair.

The Pipe Bursting Method is Safe
Excavations can pose significant safety risks due to the presence of harmful elements such as mold and asbestos which are commonly found underground. Exposure to these elements can result in serious health concerns. However, in situations where the ground is not disturbed, such as in the case of a sewer pipe bursting, the risk of exposure to these harmful elements is minimized, thereby reducing potential health hazards.

Productivity is Higher with the Pipe Bursting Method
Pipe bursting is a trenchless method of repairing pipes that has several advantages over traditional excavation methods. One of the main benefits of pipe bursting is that it significantly reduces the amount of time spent digging and cleaning up the mess, which allows workers to focus on the actual job that needs to be done. With pipe bursting, it is possible to repair up to 200m of pipe per day, depending on the specific job requirements. This method is known for its accuracy and effectiveness, making it a popular choice for many pipe repair projects.

Increase The Flow Capacity Of The Pipe with the Pipe Bursting Method
Throughout our discussions, we’ve extensively covered the numerous environmental, safety, and cost advantages of pipe bursting. However, we’ve yet to delve into the benefits that this technology offers to the functionality of the pipe itself. It’s worth highlighting that pipe bursting can significantly enhance the flow capacity of the existing pipeline by installing either a pipe of the same size or a larger one.

The Pipe Bursting Method Reduces Trench Settlement
Did you know that trenches often subside even with the best excavation jobs? This can cause pavement to settle, which not only looks unsightly but also makes it inconvenient to walk on. To address this issue, many excavation projects account for pavement settlement over time before the final paving. However, this additional step can increase the overall cost of the project. Additionally, trench settlement can negatively affect nearby utilities, as the surrounding soil shifts with the subsiding trench. It’s essential to take these factors into consideration when planning and executing excavation projects to ensure safety and prevent potential damage.

Lifetime Guarantee on Pipe Bursting Technology
If you are in need of pipe repair, it is important to choose a contractor who offers a lifetime guarantee on their pipes. Reputable contractors use high-quality, seamless pipes that are designed to prevent root intrusion and gapped joints. With the advent of trenchless technology methods, contractors are now able to offer a guarantee of work that was previously unthinkable with traditional repair methods. This means that you can rest assured that your pipes will be repaired efficiently and effectively with minimal disruption to your property.

The Pipe Bursting Process Encourages Technological Innovation
Pipe bursting is a method of replacing old or damaged pipes that has gained popularity in recent years for its many benefits. Not only does it save time and money by eliminating the need for excavation, but it also causes less disruption to the surrounding environment. However, there is also an ideological benefit to pipe bursting that often goes overlooked.

One of the advantages of using this method is that it encourages innovations in engineering. Companies and clients who choose to utilize the latest forms of technology to accomplish a particular task are opening the door for further innovation. As more and more companies continue to employ pipe-bursting procedures, they will inevitably discover ways to improve upon the method.

This process of continuous improvement can lead to the development of even better technologies and procedures that will advance the field of engineering. In fact, it is entirely possible that the pipe-bursting procedure itself could someday be replaced by a more efficient and effective method, thanks to the constant pursuit of innovation.

It is important to note that technological progress cannot occur if people continue to rely on outdated methods, such as digging ditches, to solve problems that can be solved more efficiently with advanced technologies. By embracing new and innovative methods like pipe bursting, we are not only improving our infrastructure but also paving the way for future advancements in engineering and beyond.

Need Pipe Bursting in Cincinnati?
At Curry and Son’s, we’re pipe bursting experts here in the Greater Cincinnati area. We use the latest in trenchless pipe bursting technology, so that way you can get the most bang for your buck with minimal digging to your Cincinnati home or property. Whether you need your sewer lines inspected or if you need a pipe replacement or repair in the Cincinnati area, contact our team of professional plumbers today. We’ll provide a free quote so you won’t have to guess your pipe bursting cost.

Which Trenchless Technology Is Better? Cured In Place (CIPP) vs Pipe Bursting

Sewer Pipe Line Repair

A burst sewer pipe in your home or small business is always a major inconvenience, but you can limit the impact on your wallet and stress levels by making a few smart choices about how you handle the situation. Fortunately, these days you do not need to tear up your entire yard to get at a broken sewer pipe thanks to advances in trenchless repair technology. However, choosing the right kind of trenchless repair for your particular needs takes a bit of knowledge.

While they both represent major advances in plumbing repair technology, not all of the current trenchless pipe repair techniques are as effective in different situations. When you are facing burst or leaking pipes is the worst time to try and learn about the different types of trenchless repair, so we have compiled all the necessary information for you here. Before you make a decision about how to fix your piping problems in your residence or office, it is worthwhile to take a moment to compare pipe bursting trenchless repair versus epoxy pipe lining.

What Are the Similarities?
Both of these technologies have gained broad acceptance for both residential and commercial pipe repairs since the early 1980s. Epoxy pipe lining is also known as “cured-in-place piping” (CIPP) and pipe bursting is usually known as upsizing or pipe splitting. Both of these techniques will repair your damaged sewer and water lines without needing to dig up and remove your old pipes.

The trenchless approach for solving underground piping problems saves many home and business owners a few thousand dollars every year. Both of these technologies eliminate the cost and stress of an excavation, which also helps preserve any expensive landscaping. While both of these techniques will accomplish the same goal, they each depend on very different operations.

Does Pipe Splitting Actually Burst Pipes?
Pipe splitting performs very much as advertised, using special equipment that will burst through your existing pipe, while it also expands the surrounding soil and draws replacement piping into place. This process can generally handle any diameter of piping.

The large size of the pipe-bursting equipment will require digging a pit for insertion, which means that the operation is not actually totally trenchless. Percussion forces resulting from the bursting pipe will often cause substantial ground movement that can affect the infrastructure around the work site. Pipe splitting is more risky in sandy or rocky soils, so its use always requires a thorough site study to establish the appropriateness of the conditions, and also requires a high degree of mechanical caution when in use.

How Does CIPP Work?
Cured-in-place piping involves the fabrication of materials on-site, and then the running of resin-soaked liners through your damaged sewer or water pipe lines. The two-part epoxy will cure in place, which creates a structural bond to the material of the original pipe. This way the success of the operation is independent of the surrounding soil conditions, and it will not generate any dangerous ground movement. This technology will work with any type of line including clay pipes, PVC and cast-iron drains, with an average completion time of one or two days. Most epoxy pipe lining brands come with 10-year guarantees. Unlike in the case of pipe splitting, CIPP is safe to use in virtually all types of sewer or water line repair.

Whether relining or pipe bursting is better for your needs depends on the details of your situation: how deep is your pipe, how extensive is the damage, and where is it located on your property?

Pipe bursting will cost roughly $125 to $200 for each foot, which will result in a $3,500 to $20,000 bill depending on the length of your repair. Pipe bursting is basically the underground replacement of your pipe, and the cost will depend on the depth and length of the damaged pipe.

Relining your damaged pipe will usually cost between $150 to $250 for each foot, which will result in total repair costs between $4,000 and $20,000 depending on the circumstances. Most relining operations end up costing between $6,000 and $12,000.

Since the final cost and safety of the operation depends on the exact circumstances of your problem, the first thing you should do is contact plumbing professionals who offer both services, as well as inspections and estimates.

We would love to offer you an estimate for both. Give us a call today.

Pipe Bursting Technology

Pipe Bursting will correct the following to main line, service lateral and process piping.

  • Cracked, broken or collapsed pipe
  • Severely Corroded Pipe
  • Root Infestation
  • Ground water Infiltration
  • Exfilaration of Sewage or Process Water
  • Surcharging by upsizing of the existing
Call Now